Content Harry Potter Sherlock


Cibbler posted a comment on Saturday 7th June 2008 8:33pm for The Marriage Law

lol, brilliant

Johnny Eagle posted a comment on Monday 12th May 2008 1:10am for The Marriage Law

Any chance of a prequel?

Ishtar replied:

Afraid not.   You really know everything you need to know from the story itself - how Voldemort was vanquished,  how Dumbledore fought the delaying action and how Harry et al. got together with their Significant Others is irrelevant to the point of the story, which was reversing the way the usual Marriage Law story works.   I was considering showing how Lucius, Draco and Pansy did in their marriages, but decided that adding any more to it would attenuate the humor.

phantombrick posted a comment on Wednesday 16th April 2008 9:30pm for The Marriage Law

Like it? I loved it! I had to wait almost 10 minutes to stop laughing. It is perfect poetic justice in my opinion. Tell me does Percy get his bride? Why marry Harry to Susan? Neville and Hermione? Didn't see that one coming. What about Ron and Ginny? Who got stuck with them?

Ishtar replied:

I'm glad you liked it!   Yes, Percy gets Pansy.   With the Parkinson money behind him, he eventually becomes Minister of Magic and Pansy is the perfect political wife, and they both live happily ever after.   (Actually, I intended for everyone - even Lucius and Draco - to have "happy endings" even if it took them a while to get there - I just didn't think the follow-ups would be funny enough to be good sequels to this story.)   Who exactly Harry and Hermione married was kind of irrelevant to the story, and I didn't like any of the canon relationships, so my thinking went like this: Harry needed someone with Hufflepuff loyalty, and Susan's connections in the Ministry will keep them off his back even if he doesn't go for a political career.   Neville is studious enough to satisfy Hermione and has the knowledge of the Wizarding world to let her know if one of her enthusiasms goes too far.   Ron can "claim" a Muggle-born spouse if he wants (if he gets a move on and finds one with money before someone else snaps her up.   Who knows? Maybe he saved some nice Muggle-born girl from having to marry Crabbe or Goyle.   Dumbledore certainly made sure everybody that might be affected had time to do something about it.   Ginny is too young to take advantage of the law, and it's likely to be repealed in haste before she leaves school.

Milarqui posted a comment on Sunday 2nd March 2008 12:55am for The Marriage Law

Well, if only you had made it Ginny and Ron instead of Susan Bones and Neville, it would have been perfect!

Ishtar replied:

(a) That would have been too obvious and (b) I don't like the canon pairings much - particularly Ron/Hermione.

FrequencyQueen posted a comment on Monday 21st January 2008 12:01am for The Marriage Law

Hysterical!! Great revenge on the Malfoy's.

Aelita posted a comment on Friday 4th January 2008 10:22am for The Marriage Law

This was really good and amusing, I totally didn't think it would be like this!

winterineden posted a comment on Sunday 16th December 2007 4:08am for The Marriage Law

Wow! What wicked fun!

Hemotem posted a comment on Friday 7th September 2007 6:14am for The Marriage Law

hahaha(deeeeep breath)hahahahahahahahahahaha
hahaha(Passes out from hyperventilation)


ysabet posted a comment on Wednesday 15th August 2007 4:10am for The Marriage Law

@__@................. **thud**

redwoodhouse posted a comment on Saturday 19th May 2007 1:49pm for The Marriage Law

Thanks for the wonderful laugh with Malfoy and Trelawney. Chuckle, Chunkle, Chunkle.

Thanks for the short story


Toy posted a comment on Thursday 12th April 2007 6:16pm for The Marriage Law

I really enjoyed this fic, and the very careful thought you've put into it. Thank you!

Ishtar replied:

That's high praise from one of your reputation.   Thank you.

tricia13 posted a comment on Thursday 5th April 2007 3:09am for The Marriage Law

I love it the first that i have read with this twist Great

MonCappy posted a comment on Friday 30th March 2007 3:42am for The Marriage Law

That was awesome! I like how his legislation bit him in the ass.

ladybard posted a comment on Sunday 10th December 2006 7:52am for The Marriage Law

Oh my what a riet great fun.

Fate posted a comment on Sunday 19th November 2006 12:57pm for The Marriage Law

*giggles helplessly*
This was lovely!!
Great job!

baka_onna2003 posted a comment on Sunday 12th November 2006 10:02am for The Marriage Law

EEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAKKKK!!! That was awe-inspiring. And absolutely hilarious, if my sister rolling on the floor with laughter is anything to go by.

Ivy_Snowe posted a comment on Saturday 11th November 2006 3:37pm for The Marriage Law

Yes, that was great. All your work is. Cheers.


mikek posted a comment on Saturday 4th November 2006 2:16pm for The Marriage Law

Good Twist! LOL

Luke posted a comment on Friday 3rd November 2006 11:05pm for The Marriage Law

Mean, realy mean ...

I like it *g*

Thallys posted a comment on Wednesday 1st November 2006 5:02am for The Marriage Law

Oh Gawd this is really too good, I really couldn't see that comming. Poor Malfoys and poor Parkinsons... Muahahaha !