Content Harry Potter Sherlock

Reviews

  • Previous
  • Next

dennisud posted a comment on Sunday 5th July 2015 9:30am

Neat crossover and with the modern Sherlock too! Should be fun if and when He find the Magical world and we'll see if they are all Dark wizards and being led by Voldyfarts!

What will Sherlock do? And WHERE is Harry now!

dennisud

keichan2 posted a comment on Wednesday 1st July 2015 1:16am

I like what you did with the rope: both the “no end” and the “disintegrate when damaged” were nice finds!

“cuffing him lightly with her damaged wing and grooming his dark curls with her beak” I’m sure any Harry Potter fan is now thinking the same thing as I: This is exactly Hedwig interacting with Harry!

“The bed is a statement that HPS sleeps well and has no bad dreams” OK… I was wondering who “HPS” was (or were)… Now, I wonder about the “S”: I would expect a “J”…

OK… Previous chapter, when Sherlock did spot the hidden door, it pointed at him being a Squib: a Wizard would have recognized the effect and investigated alone, to protect the Secrecy. Now, the “HPS controls the space and no one else can see it” would point at the one finding it to be Harry, provided that the array worked… Add to that the fact that Sherlock just pushed magic into the labyrinth, and my guess is that Sherlock IS Harry! (and that the Obliviation took…)

I do wonder about Watson, though… That in the previous chapter, he was able to notice the door disappearing, whereas Anderson forgot about its existence, points to Watson being at least a Squib…

You got my brain running full tilt! :-D

Thanks for the new chapter!

I hope to read more soon!

Ishtar replied:

And the next chapter should have given you the answers to some of your questions. More will be forthcoming. Yes, the interaction with Gwenwhyfar should have screamed "Hedwig!" - that's one of the reasons she's in the story at all.

JudyRaie posted a comment on Monday 29th June 2015 8:29pm

Oh my. I wonder when Sherlock will get it thru his head that he is magical also? hmmmm? I love NCIS and of course Ducky is a favorite (even as an agent from U.N.C.L.E.) LOL. Happy to have him on the case, so to speak. Keep up the good work but don't forget to stop and smell the roses along the way. :)

Lee Dickie posted a comment on Sunday 28th June 2015 5:12am

Great chapter with a well written set of analyses from the various characters especially Ducky.

Thank you.

sylvelle posted a comment on Saturday 27th June 2015 11:56pm

Interesting. Look forward to more.

Tricia

DrT posted a comment on Saturday 27th June 2015 10:22am

Wow, a lot of information that leaves me more confused (and interested) than I was before! Excellent!

Charles M Liddle posted a comment on Saturday 27th June 2015 10:03am

Very interesting chapter. I'm curious to see what the reaction of Wizarding Britain has been to Harry's disappearance. I'm assuming that Voldemort has taken control of the Ministry by now (even if behind the scenes.

Ishtar replied:

Wow, you read fast! It'll be a few chapters yet before we see what's been happening in the Wizarding world, but you can be assured things are ... different.

Jonathan Langford posted a comment on Friday 26th June 2015 9:57pm

Very cool. And soon I expect Ministry obliviators to be on the case...

keichan2 posted a comment on Wednesday 24th June 2015 7:47am

This is quite fascinating, and I REALLY wonder what happened to Harry!

Please, update soon!

Nicholas Baldwin posted a comment on Tuesday 23rd June 2015 5:13pm

I've never thought of looking for this xover before, now that I have seen it, I have be scouring FFN and other such places for this xover. Thanks for introducing me! Also, as usual, great work!

Ishtar replied:

FFNet and Archive of Our Own both have a nice selection of Sherlock/Harry crosses.

Greg Johnson posted a comment on Sunday 21st June 2015 11:15am

Very interesting story so far. Can't wait to see what happens next. Thanks for posting!

Lee Dickie posted a comment on Sunday 21st June 2015 7:42am

A great take on Sherlock. Well written and very in character. Great stuff.

starhanyou posted a comment on Saturday 20th June 2015 4:49pm

Please consider this a blanket " love your work " for everything!

JudyRaie posted a comment on Saturday 20th June 2015 1:27pm

You have me hooked! Waiting with baited breath for next chapter. Keep up th good work. As Bilbo, Dan would be great and the family resemblinse would be nice and strange at the same time since people mix up Dan and Elijia at times as it is :)

Ishtar replied:

The resemblance was what gave me the idea, actually. Likewise, since Sherlock = Benedict Cumberbatch, I needed somebody else for Smaug, and I love Jeremy Irons' voice, so ... And I realized this morning that I should have had Christopher Lee play Gandalf, since he was not only considered for the role, but he knew Tolkien personally and Tolkien wanted him to play Gandalf if they ever did a movie of it. So that's my headcanon for the movies in this 'verse.  For what it's worth.

Charles M Liddle posted a comment on Saturday 20th June 2015 9:24am

Very interesting story. It seems Sherlock is a aquib or at least has enough magic that he can see Harry's "bedroom" door. Can we hope to see Mycroft Holmes at some point? I'm not too familiar with the BBC Sherlock series; does Mycroft have the same undefined but significant role with the British Government that he had in the Conan Doyle stories? Looking forward to Chapter 3...

Ishtar replied:

In the show Mycroft is the British government, according to Sherlock. He's at least a governmental liaison with MI6 and has some sort of international influence in Asia.  In this story, Mycroft may not show up physically, but is nevertheless a strong influence: who do you think the Wizarding World has been hiding from for the last 20 years? And yeah, Sherlock's got ... something.

DrT posted a comment on Saturday 20th June 2015 4:25am

Excellent chapter; it will be interesting to see how you develop these ideas

Ishtar replied:

I have been having lots of fun with the world-building on this one.

JVTazz posted a comment on Wednesday 17th June 2015 11:37am

Good first chapter looking forward to more :)

sylvelle posted a comment on Monday 15th June 2015 12:16pm

I forsee a very bad time for.. What/s my name??? Poor thing.

Silo posted a comment on Sunday 14th June 2015 6:32pm

i hope to see family values updated soon as it is so good and agen happy to see u back

Eugene Jacobson posted a comment on Saturday 13th June 2015 2:46pm

Nice start. Hope you can keep it interesting.